Shining Tools Ltd Fair Value
SHTL · Capital Goods · Current price ₹108
| Method | Fair value | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Residual income | ₹74 | 22% ROE fading to 12% over ~10 yrs, on ₹46 book |
| Relative P/E | ₹398 | EPS × 57.9 peer-median P/E |
| Graham floor | ₹84 | Conservative floor: √(22.5 × EPS × book value/share) |
| Analyst target | — | No analyst coverage |
Is Shining Tools Ltd undervalued?
DocStoX estimates the fair value of Shining Tools Ltd at ₹167 per share, versus the current market price of ₹108. That puts the stock about +54.3% below our fair-value estimate, which we read as "Strong Buy". Our confidence in this estimate is low.
How this fair value is calculated
This estimate blends 3 independent methods: Residual income (₹74), Relative P/E (₹398), Graham floor (₹84). We weight each by its reliability and skip any method whose inputs look untrustworthy — "no DCF beats a wrong DCF". This is the same deterministic engine that powers DocStoX stock pages; there is no guesswork or AI-generated number here.
Bear, base and bull scenarios
Our scenarios span ₹74 (bear) to ₹167 (base) to ₹398 (bull). A margin of safety means buying meaningfully below the base case — the wider the gap, the more room for error in the assumptions.
More on Shining Tools Ltd
DocStoX estimates are generated by a deterministic valuation engine from reported financials — for informational purposes only, not investment advice. Consult a SEBI-registered advisor before investing.